Independent Australia columnist Alan Austin has lodged a formal complaint against the Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC) over its flagship program, Insiders. His grievance centers on what he perceives as a troubling dependency on News Corp’s content, undermining the show’s credibility. Calling for an ABC reform, the columnist detailed a list of problems ABC’s partnership with News Corp. has produced.
Contentious News Sources
Austin highlights the program’s questionable practice of frequently citing News Corp outlets. He argues that these sources, with a reputation for misinformation, compromise the show’s integrity.
Recent episodes of the Australian Broadcasting Corporation’s (ABC) program “Insiders” have sparked controversy due to their reliance on content from News Corp outlets, particularly Sky News. This trend raises questions about the program’s impartiality and journalistic standards.
On 26 November, Insiders opened with television clips reporting on events in Gaza, prominently featuring segments from Sky News. These segments have drawn criticism, as Sky News, often compared to America’s Fox News, faces accusations of misinformation and biased reporting.
News Corp Dominance in Content
The program’s segment ‘Making News’ included a review of last week’s news bulletins. Showcasing six print articles, five of which were from News Corp publications like the Herald Sun, Daily Telegraph, and Courier Mail. This heavy reliance on News Corp sources has heightened concerns about the diversity and reliability of the news presented on Insiders.
An instance that particularly stands out involved the replaying of an extended Sky News broadcast. In this segment, an Opposition shadow minister made partisan assertions against the Federal Government, which were criticized for appearing factually dubious.
Panel Composition and News Corp Influence
Further scrutiny comes from the composition of the program’s panel. Recent episodes have featured several News Corp-affiliated journalists, including James Campbell from the Herald Sun. The host, David Speers, himself a former Murdoch employee, adds to the perception of a potential bias towards News Corp’s viewpoints.
These editorial choices by ABC’s Insiders program have sparked a debate about the influence of News Corp on Australian public broadcasting. It highlights the potential impact on the credibility and impartiality of ABC’s news coverage.
News Corp’s Controversial Tactics
Austin accuses News Corp of operating more as a political machine than a news organization. He alleges that News Corp disseminates false narratives and biased reporting. He cites various examples, including News Corp’s admission in the Dominion defamation case in the USA. In the case, it was revealed that claims about the 2020 US presidential election being stolen were knowingly false.
The repercussions of these actions are far-reaching. The Dominion case settlement cost over one billion Australian dollars. However, the broader social damage, including distorted worldviews and the incitement of hate crimes, remains unrectified.
Commentator Kevin Drum wrote in 2021
‘The answer to the increasing amount of hate in our politics, then, the only answer that fits the data, is almost certainly Fox News, along with the increasing despair and commitment of conservative evangelicals… The evidence is pretty clear: it’s Fox News that’s set the country ablaze.’
The Real Source of America’s Rising Rage – Mother Jones
Dominance in Media Complaints
The Australian Press Council (APC) has upheld a significant number of complaints against News Corp. Since early 2022, 81% of the complaints upheld against all print media outlets in Australia were against Murdoch newspapers. These breaches included issues with factual accuracy, causing offence or distress, and lack of fairness and balance.
Malcolm Turnbull, former Australian Prime Minister, condemned Fox News for its significant role in polarizing American politics and fueling political animosity. His remarks, made to NPR in 2022, underscore the far-reaching influence of the outlet. Similarly, commentator Kevin Drum, in a 2021 analysis, identified Fox News as a primary catalyst for increasing hatred in political dialogues.
Impact on Society and Women
Beyond political ramifications, Austin draws attention to News Corp’s alleged role in perpetuating hate crimes and societal discord. He also condemns their targeted campaigns against prominent women in Australia, impacting figures like Gillian Triggs, Julia Gillard, and Jacinda Ardern.
As Professor Robert Manne wrote in 2016
The attack launched by The Australian on Gillian Triggs and the Human Rights Commission has been obsessive, petty, relentless, remorseless and ruthless. In ‘Bad News’ I documented similar campaigns – against Larissa Behrendt and Julie Posetti. But neither reached either the level of malevolence or the cultural significance of the current anti-Triggs campaign … What is happening to Gillian Triggs – a fine lawyer, a fine Australian, a fine human being – must be resisted with all the moral and rhetorical muscle liberal Australians can muster.
ROBERT MANNE. The Australian’s attacks on Gillian Triggs. – Pearls and Irritations (johnmenadue.com)
Calls for Global Action
In his plea for reform, Austin calls for a global effort to counter News Corp’s influence. He urges the ABC to sever ties with the organization, aligning with its charter and regaining its reputation as a credible news source.
Image Source: Independent Australia
Editor's Picks
Just in
January 7, 2024
Cairns Named in Top 10 Trending Destinations for 2024January 7, 2024
Australia’s Digital Evolution in 2023